| Platinum | Big Burger |
| Gold | Gaia's Urban Eatery |
| Silver | Papa Joe's |
| Bronze | Sizzler B-B-Q Catering since 1980 |
| Top Pick | Backwoods Burger |
| Top Pick | BOOMburger |
| Top Pick | Island Stone Pub |
| Top Pick | John Brown Richmond Street Grille |
| Top Pick | Phinley's Diner & Dairy Bar |
| Top Pick | Row House Steak & Lobster |
| Harvey's |