| Platinum | Star & Stable Christmas Store |
| Gold | Moonsnail Soapworks |
| Silver | Oh Hey PEI Stationery and Art Boutique |
| Bronze | Flower Buds |
| Top Pick | Coastal Culture |
| Top Pick | Hearts And Flowers Florist |
| Top Pick | Luna Eclectic Emporium |
| Top Pick | Northern Watters Knitwear & Tartan Shop |
| Top Pick | Red Island Handcrafted |
| Top Pick | Silver and Sage |